The Characteristics of a Great Painting: A Guide for Art Lovers

  • By:
  • Date: June 11, 2023
  • Time to read: 8 min.

Have you ever wondered what makes a good painting? Is it the technique, the subject matter, the emotions it elicits? In this article, we will explore the various elements that come together to create a truly great painting.

Color selection

Color selection is an essential part of the painting process. There is no one-size-fits-all answer to what makes good color selection, as this depends on a range of factors such as the artist’s preference, the subject matter, and the intended mood or atmosphere of the painting. However, some general tips that may help in making color selections include considering color harmonies such as complementary or analogous colors, balancing warm and cool tones, and using color to create depth and contrast. Ultimately, the key is to experiment and be open to different possibilities, as the right color selection can make all the difference in creating a successful painting.

Brushwork technique

Brushwork technique is an important aspect of painting that involves the way in which the artist applies paint to the canvas. The technique can vary depending on the type of paint being used, the desired effect, and the artist’s personal style. Some artists prefer to use short, quick strokes to create a sense of movement and energy, while others use longer, smoother strokes to create a more blended and cohesive look. Additionally, the size and shape of the brush can also affect the final result of the painting. Overall, the brushwork technique is an essential part of creating a successful painting.

Composition and balance

Composition and balance are two of the most important aspects to consider when creating a good painting. Composition refers to the arrangement of visual elements within a piece, while balance refers to the distribution of those elements. Achieving a visually interesting composition and balance requires both planning and creative intuition. It’s important to consider factors such as the focal point, contrast, and symmetry when creating a composition. The balance of these elements can create a sense of harmony or tension in the painting. But achieving the perfect balance is not easy – it requires a delicate interplay between intuition and technical skill. A good artist must be able to create a composition that feels dynamic and visually engaging, while also maintaining a sense of balance that feels natural and harmonious. It’s a tricky balancing act, and one that requires constant experimentation and refinement.

Light and shadow

Light and shadow are two essential elements in any visual art form, including painting. The interplay between light and shadow can create depth, dimension, and mood. The way an artist uses light and shadow can convey different emotions and messages to the viewer. A good painting uses light and shadow to its advantage, creating a captivating and engaging image that draws the viewer in. The technique of chiaroscuro, which involves using strong contrasts between light and dark, is often employed by artists to create dramatic and striking images. However, the use of light and shadow in a painting is not just about creating contrast. It can also be used to create softness, subtlety, and nuance. The way an artist uses light and shadow can be a reflection of their artistic style and personal vision. Overall, the use of light and shadow is a key element in creating a successful and impactful painting.

Texture and surface quality

Texture and surface quality are essential elements of a good painting. Texture refers to the tactile quality of a surface, while surface quality pertains to the overall appearance of a painting’s surface. Texture can be created through the use of various materials such as paint, pastels, and even collages. Surface quality, on the other hand, can be achieved through the application of different techniques like layering, scraping, and blending. The combination of texture and surface quality can create a truly unique and visually striking work of art.

Oil Paint Thick, buttery consistency Smooth, glossy finish
Acrylic Paint Thin, watery consistency Matte finish, can be glossy with varnish
Watercolor Paint Translucent, watery consistency Matte finish, can be glossy with varnish
Gouache Paint Opaque, creamy consistency Matte finish, can be glossy with varnish
Tempera Paint Thin, egg-like consistency Matte finish, can be glossy with varnish
Encaustic Paint Thick, waxy consistency Textured, waxy finish
Ink Liquid consistency Matte finish, can be glossy with varnish
Charcoal Powdery, smudgy consistency Matte finish
Graphite Smooth, powdery consistency Matte finish
Pastel Powdery, chalk-like consistency Matte finish, can be glossy with fixative
Colored Pencil Waxy, translucent consistency Matte finish
Oil Pastel Waxy, creamy consistency Textured, waxy finish
Spray Paint Aerosol spray Matte finish, can be glossy with varnish
Marker Ink-like consistency Matte finish
Pen Ink-like consistency Matte finish

Emotional impact

Emotional impact is one of the key elements that makes a good painting. A painting that evokes strong emotions and feelings in the viewer is considered successful. A great painting has the ability to transport the viewer to another place or time, and to provoke a range of emotional responses such as joy, sadness, wonder, or contemplation. The emotional impact of a painting is created through a combination of the artist’s skill in composition, color, and brushwork, as well as the subject matter portrayed. Whether it is a landscape, a portrait, or an abstract work, the emotional impact of a painting is what makes it memorable and timeless.

Color 7 8 6 5
Composition 9 6 4 8
Brushwork 6 7 8 5
Subject Matter 8 7 5 6

Originality and personal style

Originality and personal style are two critical aspects of what makes a good painting, but they can be challenging to pinpoint and define. Originality speaks to the artist’s ability to create something new and innovative, rather than simply replicating what has been done before. Personal style refers to the unique way in which an artist expresses themselves through their work, whether it be through technique, subject matter or other elements. The interplay between originality and personal style can be a delicate balance, as an artist must find a way to stay true to their individuality while also pushing boundaries and breaking new ground. A good painting should be both original and reflective of the artist’s personal style, but achieving this can require a great deal of experimentation, risk-taking and self-discovery.

Vincent van Gogh The Starry Night, Sunflowers, The Potato Eaters Bold, impulsive brushstrokes, thick application of paint, intense colors High
Pablo Picasso Les Demoiselles d’Avignon, Guernica, The Old Guitarist Cubism, use of multiple viewpoints, abstract shapes and forms Very High
Claude Monet Water Lilies, Impression, Sunrise, Rouen Cathedral En plein air technique, use of light and color to capture atmosphere Moderate
Salvador Dali The Persistence of Memory, The Elephants, The Hallucinogenic Toreador Surrealism, bizarre and dreamlike imagery, melting forms Very High
Rembrandt van Rijn The Night Watch, The Anatomy Lesson of Dr. Nicolaes Tulp, Self-Portrait with Two Circles Chiaroscuro, use of light and shadow, attention to detail, expressive faces Moderate
Jackson Pollock Number 1, 1950 (Lavender Mist), Convergence, Blue Poles Abstract expressionism, drip painting technique, use of unconventional tools Very High
Michelangelo David, Sistine Chapel ceiling, Pietà Realism, attention to anatomy and musculature, dramatic poses Moderate
Frida Kahlo The Two Fridas, Self-Portrait with Thorn Necklace and Hummingbird, The Broken Column Surrealism, use of vibrant colors, autobiographical themes High
Henri Matisse Dance, The Red Studio, Woman with a Hat Fauvism, bold use of color, simplified forms Moderate
Leonardo da Vinci Mona Lisa, The Last Supper, Vitruvian Man Realism, attention to detail, use of sfumato technique Moderate
Edvard Munch The Scream, Madonna, Vampire Expressionism, use of bold lines and colors to convey emotion High
Georgia O’Keeffe Red Canna, Black Iris, Cow’s Skull: Red, White, and Blue Precisionism, use of large and simplified forms, attention to details Moderate
Gustav Klimt The Kiss, Judith and the Head of Holofernes, Adele Bloch-Bauer I Art Nouveau, use of gold leaf and decorative patterns, eroticism Moderate
Diego Rivera Detroit Industry Murals, Man at the Crossroads, Flower Carrier Muralism, large-scale public art, social and political commentary Moderate
Andy Warhol Campbell’s Soup Cans, Marilyn Monroe, Elvis Presley Pop Art, use of repetition and vibrant colors, commentary on consumer culture High

Skillful execution

Skillful execution is one of the most crucial aspects of creating a good painting. It involves the artist’s ability to translate their ideas into visual form with precision and expertise. A skillful painter knows how to handle their materials, such as brushes, paint, and canvas, and can create images with a high level of technical proficiency. However, skillful execution alone does not necessarily make a painting good. It must also be paired with a strong concept, creativity, and emotional impact. Without these elements, a technically proficient painting may fall flat and fail to engage the viewer. Therefore, skillful execution is a necessary but not sufficient condition for a good painting.

Subject matter and symbolism

When it comes to understanding the meaning behind a painting, subject matter and symbolism play a crucial role. The subject matter refers to the objects, scenes, or people depicted in the painting, while the symbolism refers to the deeper meaning or message conveyed by these elements. The subject matter can be straightforward or abstract, but it is the use of symbolism that creates a sense of mystery and intrigue. A good painting, therefore, is one that not only captures the essence of the subject matter but also uses symbolism to convey a deeper meaning that is open to interpretation. This can be achieved through the use of color, composition, and other visual elements that add layers of meaning to the painting. Ultimately, a good painting is one that engages the viewer’s imagination and emotions, leaving them with a sense of wonder and awe.

Visual storytelling

Visual storytelling is the art of communicating a story through visual means. It involves the use of images, videos, and other visual media to convey a message or narrative. A good visual storyteller is able to capture the attention of their audience and keep them engaged throughout the story. They are able to convey complex ideas and emotions through the use of simple visuals, and they have a deep understanding of the power of imagery. Visual storytelling can be found in a variety of mediums, including film, photography, animation, and graphic design. By using compelling imagery and creative techniques, visual storytellers are able to create powerful and memorable stories that resonate with their audience.

What makes a painting good?

A good painting is subjective and can vary from person to person. However, some qualities that are generally considered important in a good painting include composition, color harmony, technique, and emotional impact.

What is composition?

Composition refers to the arrangement of elements within a painting. A well-composed painting has a balanced distribution of elements, such as shapes, lines, colors, and values, that lead the viewer's eye throughout the painting.

What is color harmony?

Color harmony refers to the pleasing relationship between colors within a painting. Colors that are harmonious create a sense of unity and balance, while colors that clash can create tension and discord.

What is technique?

Technique refers to the skill and mastery of the artist in handling the medium used for the painting. This includes brushwork, paint application, and the ability to create texture and depth.

What is emotional impact?

Emotional impact refers to the ability of a painting to evoke feelings or emotions in the viewer. A good painting can make the viewer feel happy, sad, inspired, or contemplative, among other emotions.

In conclusion, a good painting is a combination of various factors such as the artist’s skill, use of color, composition, and emotional impact. A good painting not only looks visually appealing but also has the ability to evoke emotions and convey a message. It is a work of art that can stand the test of time and continue to inspire and captivate viewers for generations to come.

does paint make you high

Previous Post

The Truth About Paint Fumes: Can They Really Make You High?

Next Post

5 Best Types of Spray Paints for Creating Stunning Artwork

what to use for spray paint art